The Two Thousand Dollar Man
An enslaved millwright searches for his family as Sherman’s campaign reaches Savannah, while a Confederate private’s last news travels home by letter.
Watch on YouTube ↗ · Published
Lyrics
Two thousand dollars in the Chatham probate ink,
Written down in tidy figures by a clerk who didn't think,
Two thousand for the millwright, for the gears I'd learned by hand,
For the dam I knew by soundness and the timber on the land.
They split my house like cordwood when the winter debts came due,
Sent Lucy down to Macon, and my Jonas — no one knew.
There's no column for the sorrow, so the sorrow wasn't shown,
Just two thousand in the margin, and the balance of a loan.
Across the Ogeechee in Bryan lived a boy without a team,
Working rented sandy acres on a tenant's thinning dream.
When the drums came from Savannah with the ribbons and the band,
He took a rifle for a Cause that never gave him land.
Eleven dollars every month to stand where shells are thrown,
To guard the planter's parlor while the weeds took all his own.
Who writes the price upon a man in ink or crimson mud?
Who weighs a chain against a wage, a ledger against blood?
For both of us were weighed against another man's estate:
One kept inside the ledger book, one spent outside the gate.
He wrote his mother from Virginia that the shoes had left his feet,
That a rich man's war in parlor talk is a poor man's winding sheet.
In December on the river I heard Sherman's guns come down,
When McAllister was taken and the smoke rolled toward the town.
One of us was worth two thousand if he stayed inside the chain,
One of us was worth eleven dollars, dying in the rain.
Who writes the price upon a man in ink or crimson mud?
Who weighs a chain against a wage, a ledger against blood?
For both of us were weighed against another man's estate:
One kept inside the ledger book, one spent outside the gate.
Don't tell me we were brothers, don't tell me it was the same:
He went to war a poor man, but he went there in his name.
And I stood upon the ledger where my name was barely penned,
Between the mule and the millstones, with a number at the end.
The boy came home in a letter in a sergeant's careful hand,
And the weeds had all his acres, and the planter all his land.
I walked to Macon in the spring with no pass to show the guard,
Asked for Lucy at the churches, asked for Jonas in the yards.
Now I stand beside the river, holding back the water's weight,
No price upon my shoulders and no master at the gate,
But the only page that bears my name is the page that bore my price.
Lucy's on line eleven...
Jonas isn't on the page.
Two figures in the ballad
The song follows two fictional men from coastal Georgia. A probate inventory values an enslaved millwright in Chatham County at two thousand dollars. When the estate’s debts come due, his family is sold apart. Across the Ogeechee in Bryan County, a tenant farmer enlists as a Confederate private. The inventory records a price imposed on a person held as property. The soldier’s pay measures what the army offers him for his service.
Savannah and the Ogeechee
On December 13, 1864, Union troops captured Fort McAllister on the Ogeechee River, opening a supply route for Sherman’s army as it approached Savannah. The city fell on December 21. The song uses these events to bring the millwright’s search and the soldier’s letters into the same winter.
Family separation and freedom
A firsthand account of the March 1859 slave auction in Savannah records buyers breaking up families. It provides historical context for the fictional sale in the song. The millwright’s spring journey to Macon takes up a question emancipation left unresolved for separated families: where to begin looking when the people who sold them controlled the records of where they went.